The Gaardian Aardwolf Notes Archive

display all notes from
on the board
between and
containing the phrase

showing 50 most recent notes by Redryn
bragging right pin for reaching rank 5 epic? ++
Note #41244
posted on Ideas
Friday, February 1, 2019 @ 08:23
Reply to: Note 41243 posted by Tryllus

Not all current epics track completions, so the data is going to be patchy.
Re: Kingsholm Goal
Note #41208
posted on Ideas
Friday, January 25, 2019 @ 19:27
Reply to: Note 41207 posted by Crowley

Been a long time, but I thought they don't see invis?
Re: cabal
Note #18252
posted on Bugs
Wednesday, January 23, 2019 @ 05:13
Reply to: Note 18251 posted by Quarana

Doesn't eqsearch already indicate that an item is invis?

That's also stated in the eqsearch help file.
Re: Reduce Strangle Duration in PK +
Note #41190
posted on Ideas
Friday, January 18, 2019 @ 07:07
Reply to: Note 41189 posted by Garfield

Is strangle duration actually so long? That's not been my experience - maybe
1 tick or so, but please correct me if I'm mistaken.

Or are you confusing strangle with the sleep spell?
Re: Instinct/Mastery totals ++++
Note #41172
posted on Ideas
Sunday, January 13, 2019 @ 01:02
Reply to: Note 41171 posted by DjVoltron

Why in the world would anyone care what the total number of random instincts
is? It's a pretty meaningless number compared to individual instinct amounts or
total trains used
Re: Instinct/Mastery totals ++
Note #41170
posted on Ideas
Sunday, January 13, 2019 @ 00:51
Reply to: Note 41169 posted by DjVoltron

You can already use instinct check to see how much you've put into instinct.
Re: Gquest timers
Note #41151
posted on Ideas
Friday, January 4, 2019 @ 10:35
Reply to: Note 41149 posted by Quarana

The downside to having a long time-out is that it holds up the queue for
everyone else (no other 10 or fewer wins gq will be called while one is
ongoing). A timeout was added to prevent issues if someone decides to 
go afk for example.

The timer (10 mins) resets every time you kill a mob, so it can actually
be very long. 10 minutes should be plenty of time to find any mob - learn
to use maps instead of wandering around aimlessly, and if you realise some
area is particularly troublesome, take a quick break to kill an easy mob
to reset the timer.
Re: Shop Item Restriction +
Note #41132
posted on Ideas
Tuesday, January 1, 2019 @ 09:08
Reply to: Note 41131 posted by VeryLongName

Uh, isn't that exactly what setting a pagesize does?
Re: runto kflag
Note #18211
posted on Bugs
Thursday, December 27, 2018 @ 20:38
Reply to: Note 18210 posted by Bitties

I think kflag is at the Aylorian forge, just south of the weapon forge which
runto erroneously brings you to.
GQ concept to defeat SnD /scripts ++++
Note #41083
posted on Ideas
Wednesday, December 19, 2018 @ 10:39
Reply to: Note 41082 posted by Mendaloth

> The idea that you can somehow defeat scripts with complicated factors such as
> mazes and randomized zones is just not true.  The only thing that is possible
> is to raise the bar and skill level required for those making the scripts.

You're right, but I think that's the point. Unlike popular graphical games
where there are millions of players and always people willing to pay money
for the development of scripts, etc, Aard isn't that widely popular, and it
isn't exactly the target of the proverbial bot farms that make gold (or
whatever) to sell to other players for irl money.

If the bar is sufficiently high, the vast majority will not have the ability
or time to develop scripts for it.

I believe it is possible to design minizones that are hard to script, and even
then a script is not likely to give a significant advantage over a human.
E.g.: a miniboss like morgak (dodge the exploding runes). Don't think a script
gives a significant boost. Don't even know if anyone's even written a script
for it.

I should also point out that a fully automated maze-solver is illegal.
Re: GQ concept to defeat SnD /scripts +++
Note #41081
posted on Ideas
Wednesday, December 19, 2018 @ 09:48
Reply to: Note 41077 posted by Vespar

I think there was some work done on creating random instanced zones. That
concept could translate into a temporary zone where a bunch of players
compete to complete some sort of objective (find kill a mob/ find item, or

Perhaps there could also be various "fixed" minizones within the mazes that
could have similar designs or mechanics to pass - this would reward some 
degree of knowledge/exploration of such random zones, and which of these
minizones that pop up could be randomised. Depending on what's randomised in
it, it could be easy for a player who knows them to figure out, but hard for
a script to do the same.

Could even have minibosses that you had to defeat using certain mechanics.

Could be designed with a portal entry/ portal exit after completing the
minizone, and plugged into any section. Players could perhaps even
design such minizones that could be added to the pool.

Re: Directional Sign in Aerial City of Cineko +
Note #41060
posted on Ideas
Saturday, December 15, 2018 @ 23:53
Reply to: Note 41059 posted by Tymme

+1, I think find could be expanded to be used more generally. Maybe can unlock
the keywords once the room is explored.

Would also make it easier for those who don't use mappers.
Re: GQs & CPs +
Note #41050
posted on Ideas
Saturday, December 15, 2018 @ 23:08
I don't understand the logic behind the suggestion, at least for GQs.
The reason t9 redos had cp rewards cut is because it was possible to earn a
massive amount of qps (e.g. 3-5k a day) which was seen to break the game  
GQs are not a massive source of qps since they don't occur frequently.
There is no mechanic in the game which cuts rewards after hitting a certain
total, which seems to be what you're suggesting.
What benefit does your suggestion bring?
As for CPs, I think it would at best only make sense to extend the per-day
limit to non-t9 redos, but again I don't think any total cap should be
added. It would be unfair to newer players vs older players who have done 10k+
cps without caps.
Re: Imm pills/potions +
Note #41013
posted on Ideas
Saturday, December 8, 2018 @ 08:13
Reply to: Note 41012 posted by Zagyg

Sure players get a good boost, for all of about 15 minutes maybe. Is that
really a problem?
And if the boost is valuable, prices for such pills will go up significantly
Re: spellup str
Note #18196
posted on Bugs
Saturday, December 8, 2018 @ 00:52
Reply to: Note 18195 posted by Sotura

Are you in a room with a mob with a keyword that "str" would hit?
Imm pills/potions
Note #41010
posted on Ideas
Saturday, December 8, 2018 @ 00:14
It would be cool if imm pills/triv pots/special limited pills/pots would 
give a random subclass spell buff, e.g. desecration, power projection, 
timeshifting, gaia, etc.

Would make them give a tangible and significant boost, as the stat bonuses
that you currently get are of limited utility to maxxed out players
Re: SH drink ++
Note #18183
posted on Bugs
Friday, November 30, 2018 @ 21:36
Reply to: Note 18182 posted by Dillon

Superheroes don't get hungry or thirsty, don't need the wish
Re: Awareness
Note #40970
posted on Ideas
Thursday, November 29, 2018 @ 08:54
Reply to: Note 40965 posted by Dillon

The main point of awareness is to block the backstab skill,
not to add resistance (which would protect against all damage).
Re: epics ++
Note #40943
posted on Ideas
Wednesday, November 28, 2018 @ 09:38
Reply to: Note 40942 posted by Avandar

I think shorter repop times + personal timers is the way to go, such as in
Winds. Addresses timezone issues while not significantly increasing the
number of runs. E.g. repop timer of 30 hours + 72 hour personal timer = 1-2
runs per week. In fact, ideally the repop timer could be even shorter so
multiple timezones could organise runs on weekends (where most people are

Not sure about adjusting difficulty since that needs a lot of work and
extensive rewriting if the epic doesn't already permit it.

I think IF1 and IF2 points should be separated, although I think it would
be nice if people with lots of IF2 runs already (e.g. me) could get some
of the points converted to IF2 points. Should be fairly straightforward
to calculate based on #runs x 15 points.
Re: navigator bypass
Note #40893
posted on Ideas
Monday, November 19, 2018 @ 23:29
Reply to: Note 40889 posted by Tymme

As much as I would like to see this as a navigator, I think that would make
it way too unfair for all other participants in a GQ.

Especially since bypass typically is used on all the tedious areas like
D8, Partroxis, etc.
Re: Gag / gameplay.
Note #40870
posted on Ideas
Saturday, November 17, 2018 @ 04:51
Reply to: Note 40868 posted by Starling

Justifications for punishments include, apart from rehabilitation, deterrence
and prevention (and some say retribution). 

If the only punishment for bad conduct is to preventive in nature (i.e.
preventing them from talking on channels), then there's limited to no deterrent
effect. I.e. a player will just figure that the worst that happens for breaking
conduct rules is they don't get channel access for a period of time.

Punishments that are wider than just that have a deterrent effect, because the
player will realise that breaking rules hurts them beyond just that.
That's why we also have punishments like jail, freeze, or nuke.

That said, I don't see an issue with a specific nochan vs gag all distinction,
although I would say the liberty should remain with imms to decide whatever
punishment is most appropriate.

From what I've seen though, the usual nochan punishment for non-repeat
rule breakers tends to be shortlived in nature, and which usually serves its
Re: Goal Reset
Note #40857
posted on Ideas
Wednesday, November 14, 2018 @ 10:06
Reply to: Note 40853 posted by Androg

Issue is that goals aren't set up for it. Some goals give rewards midway
through (e.g. academy fundraising leaflet) and there's no way for the system
to know when an item given is a 'reward', or random goal-related item. 

One idea raised before is to allow resets of goals on tiers (and allow
collecting the reward again), not sure what happened to that.
Re: Group exp +
Note #40856
posted on Ideas
Wednesday, November 14, 2018 @ 10:01
Reply to: Note 40851 posted by Abelinc

The concern I would have is that t9 redoers tend to have low tnl but very
high levelling speed. If this is implemented, it could bring a whole new
type of superdragging (i.e. t9 redoer drags someone, and they basically get
super kill speed + almost permanent double exp from the t9 redoer).

Not sure that's necessarily a good thing.

Also, when would the 0tnl "lock" kick in? Is it when someone is about to level
out of the 15 level range? Or does it bring everyone to the same level?

If the former - it would exacerbate the hyper dragging concern. If the latter,
it would really mess up the usual group dynamic. Plenty of people have
different tnls and don't necessarily want their levels to be locked to whoever
else is in their group, especially since by definition it slows down their
levelling speed.
Re: Merging Random Epic Items Together +
Note #40855
posted on Ideas
Wednesday, November 14, 2018 @ 09:55
Reply to: Note 40850 posted by Wire

I've suggested before the idea of temporary stronger items. E.g. you could
merge 2 rank5 into a rank6, but the item has a timer and will crumble 
within 1 month.

To me that gives something to do (forever), while not creating power creep.

Re: Sloth Effect removal at Clan/Manor/Aylor Healer ++
Note #40845
posted on Ideas
Monday, November 12, 2018 @ 00:26
Reply to: Note 40844 posted by Impurifan

Castiel already pointed to help gq rules...

See also help policies6

The only exception to this teamwork is global quests.  Winning a gquest is
an individual accomplishment and aid on global quests has a negative impact
on the other participants. It is illegal to have others repeatedly kill a
gquest mob you have already killed, kill key mobs, attack a gquest mob and
remove weapons, etc. 

Sure it's not specifically listed, but it seems obvious to me that slothing
someone is just the same as the other examples listed.
Re: Icefall 2 +
Note #40835
posted on Ideas
Saturday, November 10, 2018 @ 21:38
Reply to: Note 40834 posted by Srykr

15 points is with the ring, 10 points is base I believe.
Re: Sloth Effect removal at Clan/Manor/Aylor Healer +
Note #40800
posted on Ideas
Tuesday, November 6, 2018 @ 22:52
Reply to: Note 40797 posted by Castiel

Insofar as Tram casted sloth on Wire during gq as "payback" seems to be an
admission of breaking the rules...

But anyway, agree with the original idea. The point of sloth was to help
pk by preventing someone from getting away. If they can make it to clan/manor
etc, they've already gotten away. No reason for making things
unplayable until it wears off, which is mostly an issue
in gqs (you can afk for a few mins otherwise). I had
 a random aggro mob cast it on me once, and it was hellish.
Re: Increasing participation in games +
Note #40758
posted on Ideas
Wednesday, October 31, 2018 @ 11:19
Reply to: Note 40757 posted by Tymme

Please don't add rewards to the point where people feel obligated to join
activities or they are "losing out" on rewards.

My reasons for not playing stuff - 
Blackjack/Slots - it's just basic gambling with statistical loss, 
Poker - it's gambling + I don't know how to play well
Mafia - party game, not something I'd play over and over again, and more fun
        IRL tbh, when you can try to read people's expressions etc.
Laser - Scripts give huge advantage.

The above also aren't quite in line with the Aard game mechanics, i.e. an RPG
/ hacknslash. They're minigames, not the focus of the mud.

Wars - the participation rate is low, and the outcome of most wars is
predetermined (i.e. based on participants' stats, you know who will win). 

It could be vastly improved with randomised team wars. Have suggested this
ad nauseam. Randomised teams would mean people have a more or less 50:50 chance
of winning, even if teams are imbalanced. Odds get closer and closer the larger
the teams get. 

I think laser could be reworked into some sort of arena mini-game where
character stats don't matter as much, and ideally can't be scripted. Possibly
add some delay/lag to movement, and have make it possible to dodge shots? 

I've seen various minigame series that are mods of other popular games, where
there are a bunch of randomised minigames that players will do (e.g. Uther
Party in Warcraft 3, that I can think of offhand). One game which would
probably translate well to aard would be bomberman maybe?
The classic NES tanks game too I suppose. 
Re: Item error color codes?
Note #16832
posted on Typos
Sunday, October 28, 2018 @ 23:30
Reply to: Note 16831 posted by Irmie

I think the @@ is supposed to represent the head of a mace.
Re: PVP Tier Restrictions +
Note #40708
posted on Ideas
Saturday, October 27, 2018 @ 02:59
Reply to: Note 40707 posted by Gilduran

45 level difference is insane, maybe 2 or 3 levels a tier would make sense.
Re: Aard EQ ++
Note #40692
posted on Ideas
Friday, October 26, 2018 @ 12:44
Reply to: Note 40690 posted by Icarus

Since when is disarm a very useful pvp skill?
Re: Aard EQ
Note #40688
posted on Ideas
Friday, October 26, 2018 @ 12:37
Reply to: Note 40684 posted by Icarus

> I propose the affect from the Bracers of Iron Grip be changed from NoDisarm, which
> completely voids a very useful PVP skill,

Since when is iron grip a very useful pvp skill?
Re: Ally Chat +
Note #40679
posted on Ideas
Friday, October 26, 2018 @ 01:02
Reply to: Note 40676 posted by Tymme

I believe this has been rejected before because allies aren't consistent (like
flist). Someone who replies to you might have their message
sent to someone not your Ally.
Dusk Valley - Rylek sorcerer & Rylek harmer +++
Note #16804
posted on Typos
Monday, October 22, 2018 @ 09:29
Reply to: Note 16799 posted by Abelinc

> But a spell doesn't know how many words are in TWO of its positional 
> parameters, making the need for single-quotes required to know when one
> argument ends and another starts. It could be rewritten to be slightly
> smarter which would eliminate this particular issue, in that the third
> (optional) argument of the target is always the last.

You mean this? I believe the point of Zoot's note is that she never understood
why quotes are needed for spell targets, your response was that this was
because casting has 2 parameters, to which I responded to say that it's not
really an answer, because cast always assumes the first parameter is a single
word anyway.
Dusk Valley - Rylek sorcerer & Rylek harmer +++
Note #16798
posted on Typos
Monday, October 22, 2018 @ 02:16
Reply to: Note 16796 posted by Abelinc

> For spells, it's much more difficult:
> 1) First word is cast
> 2) Second and maybe third words are spell
> 3) What I'm acting on may start at the third or fourth words, 
>    and may go farther out than that

Except even for spells, the third word is always considered to be the target,
unless the spell name is in quotes.
c indestructible aura -> They aren't here.

Since it already assumes any multi-word spellname will be in quotes, there is
no reason not to treat any subsequent words as target.
Re: lottery
Note #555
posted on Misc
Monday, October 22, 2018 @ 01:56
Reply to: Note 553 posted by Abelinc

Not every lottery bet is statistically loss making. Especially with rollover of
prize monies, sometimes you have a statistical positive expected value. 

See e.g. the story of Jerry Selbee.
Raise the number of items allowed in manors +++
Note #40626
posted on Ideas
Sunday, October 14, 2018 @ 05:15
Reply to: Note 40625 posted by Thridi

Clan potions are already 'static' flagged, so it doesn't save the individual
item data
Re: Raise the number of items allowed in manors ++
Note #40620
posted on Ideas
Saturday, October 13, 2018 @ 23:57
Reply to: Note 40619 posted by Fiendish

I thought since we moved to v3, the old 'vnums' are no longer relevant, and
there are virtually unlimited item keys possible. I don't think it makes a
difference to storage either...
Re: Item limits +++
Note #40590
posted on Ideas
Monday, October 8, 2018 @ 11:29
Reply to: Note 40589 posted by Uuna

To clarify, friend makes the mule account, so it's not multiplaying
Re: Item limits +
Note #40587
posted on Ideas
Monday, October 8, 2018 @ 10:10
Reply to: Note 40586 posted by Mordist

(1) I didn't suggest removing item limits altogether (i.e. unlimited capacity),
    so the amount you'd end up carrying is the same as now;

(2) I don't think the change would increase hoarding. People already deal with
    the limits by just asking a friend to hold on to their stuff (whether on
    their main char or by making a mule account to hold it).
Item limits
Note #40585
posted on Ideas
Monday, October 8, 2018 @ 10:04
Could item limits be changed to either (1) a fixed limit, or (2) based on
saved SH stats?

Currently, if you have maxxed stats at SH (and presumably high str), when you
remort or redo, you lose about 400-500 item slots, and it's a huge hassle
trying to clear up inventory space in order to do so. I'm not sure what this
really adds to the game.
Re: sh campaigns
Note #40570
posted on Ideas
Friday, October 5, 2018 @ 13:40
Reply to: Note 40568 posted by Zoot

I quite like this idea. It's been ages since I've gone to a low level area for
any reason.
Re: Website out of date
Note #16766
posted on Typos
Wednesday, October 3, 2018 @ 23:41
Reply to: Note 16765 posted by Redryn

Actually, should be checked and
updated (or removed if too much hassle maybe).

- Classes doesn't refer to subclass system
- Spells and skills list not updated
- Clan list not updated
- Tier bonuses not up to date

Or maybe link to the wiki instead.
Website out of date
Note #16765
posted on Typos
Wednesday, October 3, 2018 @ 22:28

Still refers to the old stat system with max of 350 + 150.
Re: Mob affect idea +
Note #40544
posted on Ideas
Tuesday, October 2, 2018 @ 21:10
Reply to: Note 40543 posted by Fiendish

Sounds like a terra boss mob.
Aylor room became unexplored
Note #18099
posted on Bugs
Sunday, September 30, 2018 @ 08:11
For some reason the Aylor pclass warrior training room became unexplored for
me, which is rather a pain since I don't really want to classchange into pwar
just for the explore...
Re: Arboretum bug ++
Note #18098
posted on Bugs
Saturday, September 29, 2018 @ 23:15
Reply to: Note 18097 posted by Throxx

I just went to get a thorn, it was lvl 110. Maybe you're using the wrong
Re: Arboretum bug
Note #18096
posted on Bugs
Saturday, September 29, 2018 @ 23:13
Reply to: Note 18095 posted by Throxx

Thorn is lv 110?
Re: New Feature - Fishing
Note #40518
posted on Ideas
Friday, September 28, 2018 @ 02:16
Reply to: Note 40517 posted by Nid

You can already go fishing in Sen'narre or Nalondir. Doesn't seem
like a popular feature.
Re: The Covenant of Mistridge - a peasant girl
Note #16757
posted on Typos
Wednesday, September 26, 2018 @ 23:53
Reply to: Note 16756 posted by Sammael

Not a typo, it has "girl". Being a descriptor isn't a reason to add as keyword.